Saw a maintenance-band clip and had thoughts

2026-11-15 747 views 1 post

Saw a short video this morning arguing that maintenance should be a hard five-pound band, not a vague around-goal zone. My first reaction was skeptical, because I lift four days a week and my weight bounces 1–2 lb from sodium alone.

What I do agree with: a narrow band makes you check weekly averages instead of one scary morning. My own setup is a 3 lb range around my target, protein at every meal, sleep logged, and I only tweak carbs after two weeks of the average drifting.

I care mre about my main lifts holding than a random Tuesday number. For people further out than me, does a tight band help or just create noise?

Curious how you define your range without letting the scale run the day.