Why do I feel the need to prove I'm not cheating?

Sep 30

Small vent, maybe a question. I'm 14 weeks in, down 22 lbs (5'6", started at 194, sitting around 172 now). I lift three mornings a week and walk the dog two miles most evenings. Nothing heroic.

But lately I catch myself doing weird stuff. Adding an extra set after someone at work says "you must be on that shot." Posting a sweaty gym mirror photo to prove I'm not taking the easy route. Which is silly. In the trials, the weight loss mostly tracks back to appetite and how fast the stomach empties; the lifting is just to hang onto muscle while I lose. I know that. And I still want to look tough about it.

Honestly my habits barely changed. Same protein shake, same chicken and rice, same single coffee. The only real difference is I'm not white-knuckling dinner anymore, and that's it.

Does anyone else get that urge to overperform when people make comments? Or have you figured out how to just let it roll off?

👍 6 ❤️ 1

Saturday at 1:37 AM

God, I relate. First time I lost ~30, I turned every compliment into a weird audition—extra cardio, posting gym selfies nobody asked for. Then I regained and felt like I’d been caught faking. This time I keep a note on my phone with three non-scale wins each week: waist down half an inch, squatted bodyweight, didn’t need a nap after the dog walk. When I get the “must be cheating” itch, I read that instead of adding a set. Curious—if no one at work ever mentioned it again, what would you want your workouts to look like? That answer usually tells me who I’m actually trying to convince.

👍 3

Monday at 6:35 PM

Tbh something that helped me: I made a private list of “non-scale receipts”—new belt notch, leash not tugging my shoulder, carrying both dog food bags from the car in one trip. When the prove-it urge hits, I read that instead of adding a set or posting. It separates my actual life from the imaginary jury. Gentle question: does the urge spike more with certain people, like coworkers vs.

👍 5

Tuesday at 9:13 AM

I ran a dumb experiment: tagged workouts as “witnessed” or “unwitnessed” for two weeks. Same lifts, same walks. The witnessed ones weren’t more effective—they just carried extra anxiety. Dropping the audience cost me zero progress. Now if I catch myself adding a set for the peanut gallery, I ask: is this training or testimony? If it’s testimony, I skip it. What’s your tell—extra cardio after a comment, or the mirror selfie?

👍 9 ❤️ 2

Yesterday at 5:37 AM

I keep a private "receipts" note: 7-day weight average, waist at navel, and how many consecutive dog walks. When someone says "must be the shot," I don't argue—I just look at the trend. Last month my weight spiked 1.8 lbs after a pizza night, but the 7-day line was flat and my waist was down 0.5". If I'd been performing for an audience, I'd have added a fourth lift day for no reason. The extra set after that comment is your brain seeking a permission slip. What would you track if no one ever saw it?

👍 4