My trendline got quieter after I fixed one date

2026-11-11 2052 views 5 posts

I keep a weekly sheet with a 7-day rolling average and a separate sleep row. Tuesday I noticed my trendline had flattened at 0.3 lb down, which felt wrong, so I checked the source rows.

I’d entered Monday’s weight on Sunday’s date. Fixing that one cell changed the average to 0.1 lb down and, weirdly, made the whole week feel less dramatic.

My sleep row also went from 7:10 to 6:35 on the three nights I ate later, and that lined up with my low-energy notes better than the scale did. Mildly contrarian conclusion: the daily number is mostly noise; the rolling average and the sleep row are the only columns I’m trusting this month.

Does anyone else audit their own rows before blaming the plan?

yep i split “weigh time” and “sheet date” after doing almost the same thing with a post-midnight weigh-in. mine was a friday scale sync that landed on thursday, so the 7-day avg ate a stale number twice.

i added a helper column that flags if timestamp and date differ by >12h and it caught two more. did your sleep row stay on monday or did it shift too?

that mght be why the week felt less dramatic.

Honestly, I’d push back on treating the 7-day as the trend. Mine swings enough that one corrected cell can flip the headline, so I use a 14-day window and annotate corrections instead of expecting the old “dramatic” week back.

Same with sleep: I only interpret it against a 2-week baseline, not a single week. The quieter number is probably more honest.

Are you using 7-day only, or do you keep a longer window for actual decisions?

Ha, the “less dramatic” part is the tell — one data-entry slip was narrating the week. I don’t make much of a same-day rolling average; I keep a 4-week median and a little “data quality” flag, and if I edit a date I leave the flag until the next full week so I don’t over-read the recalculated line.

There was a thread last year about “one bad Sunday” doing exactly this. Did your sleep row move with the corrected date, or is it still keyed to the original day?

That mismatch would explain the quieter curve.

I’ve got a “conditions” column next to my weigh-ins—salty dinner, late workout, under 6h sleep—and it’s the only thing keeping me sane in a four-week flat patch. When my rolling average goes quiet, I check that column before I touch the spreadsheet again; half the time it’s water/logistics, not a real stall.

Does your sleep row ever explain the quieter weeks, or do you keep it completely separate from the weight math?